Sotomayor v. Kagan

2 thoughts on “Sotomayor v. Kagan”

  1. I agree with Joseph, and raise him one step further: it was not only not a “sucker punch,” it was an appalling blunder. It’s an elementary rule of oral advocacy that you don’t challenge the premise of a justice’s hypothetical, and I can’t remember the last time a solicitor general made such a basic mistake.

Comments are closed.